YouTube removed four LiveActionFilms videos for "content inappropriate" from its site during the last 2 weeks of August without giving any warning.
The oldest video had been on the site for over a year and the most recent for over four months In total these videos have received over 160,000 views. The content in these videos is not violent, profane, or sexually explicit. We encourage you to watch the 4 banned videos at the bottom of this page.
Google CEO Eric Schmidt asked on-camera September 4th why the Live Action Films videos were removed from YouTube!
Updated link...
What Live Action is Doing
On August 27, 2008 we called Google (who runs YouTube) to discuss why our videos were removed. We were told to complete an online dispute form, which we did that day. However,YouTube has not responded after two weeks and has not told us why the video were removed.
Why YouTube Must Stop Censorship of the Videos
1) The content of the videos does not violate YouTube standards. In fact, two of the videos that were taken down remain on the channels of YouTube users. 2) YouTube has restored removed videos before, usually in response to public outcries for fairness. 3) People like you will help us pressure YouTube to remain a non-ideological, fair, and free medium for communication.
The Four Videos Banned by YouTube
#1: PART I: Planned Parenthood Racism Investigation DESCRIPTION: PP Part 1: Video plays audio and transcripts of Planned Parenthood of Ohio and Idaho accepting racist donations from callers to target Blacks for abortion.
Another YouTube user also has the same video on their channel yet it was not taken down.
#2: PART II: Planned Parenthood Racism Investigation DESCRIPTION: PP Part 2: Video plays recorded audio and transcripts of PP of New Mexico and Oklahoma accepting racist donations from callers to target Blacks for abortion.
#3: Autumn's Response: PART I Planned Parenthood Racism DESCRIPTION: Autumn's Response: Video includes content of PP Part 1, as well as the "excited" response of PP employee Autumn Kersey to the racist donation.
DOWNLOAD AS MP4
#4: Rush Limbaugh on Planned Parenthood Racism Investigation
DESCRIPTION: Rush Limbaugh: Rush comments on investigative videos of PP racist donations produced by student activists.
Another YouTube user also has the same video on their channel yet it was not taken down.
History of Discriminatory YouTube Censorship
July 2, 2008
YouTube.com, in what the Population Research Institute (PRI) is calling a case of blatant censorship, has removed a video from its website for the sole reason that it criticizes a pro-abortion journalist. (source)
April 2008
" Google refused to run ads for a UK Christian group opposed to abortion, explaining that "At this time, Google policy does not permit the advertisement of websites that contain 'abortion and religion-related content.'" Google policy does not prohibit advertisements for abortion clinics or pro-choice sites." (source)
Feb. 19, 2008
YouTube also removed a video produced by the American Life League which is critical of Planned Parenthood. It has since been restored. (source)
Nov. 12, 2007
At Google, we have a bias in favor of people's right to free expression," Brand said. "Google is not and should not become the central arbiter of what does and does not appear on the Web. (source)
"We do not allow articles and sources expressly promoting hate speech viewpoints in Google News, although referencing hate speech for commentary and analysis is acceptable". (source)
October 2007
" Google banned advertisements from Maine U.S. Senator Susan Collins' reelection campaign, citing its trademark policy. The ads contained the words "Help Susan Collins stand up to the MoveOn.org money machine." At the time, Google permitted the use of company names like Exxon and Wal-Mart in other non-sanctioned advertising, and an ad running at the time of the article read "Keep Blackwater in Iraq?" (source)
June, 2007
World Ahead president Eric M. Jackson tells the Sinclair network's evening news that the Google Adwords editorial policy seems to have a liberal bias.
May 10, 2007
"Shareholders of Google voted down an anti-censorship proposal for the company. CEO Eric Schmidt and founders Larry Page and Sergey Brin recommended that shareholders vote against the proposal. Together they hold 66.2 percent of Google's total shareholder voting power." (source)
Oct. 12, 2006
Don't think it matters? Consider that, according to USA Today, 98 percent of the money donated to political parties by Google employees — "Google Millionaires" — went to Democrats. (source)
Oct. 12, 2006
"YouTube blocked video mocking Clinton administration."
"It has in the past censored various Christian-themed ads, but allowed porn ads." WorldNetDaily Article
Oct. 9, 2006
"company took a scrub bucket to some questionable political graffiti on its servers, including a video entry from the doyenne of right-wing blogs, Michelle Malkin." New York Times Article See the Malkin video that was removed.
May, 2006
In early 2006 Google removed several news sites from its news search engine because complaints were received about various articles that were critical of Islam. (source)
1) Contact YouTube through their web form and ask them why specifically the Live Action Films videos were removed and request that they restore the "LiveActionFilms" videos. Go HERE then click "Report abuse" then "General policy inquiry".
2) Call YouTube at (650-343-2960) and ask them why specifically the Live Action Films videos were removed and request that they restore the "LiveActionFilms" videos. It's an answering machine that says they're experiencing "high call volume". Be sure to leave a message.
3) Email your friends and tell your Facebook and MySpace friends to visit this page and join the effort.
Mid-Late August - YouTube removes 4 videos for "content inappropriate".
August 27 - Live Action requests YouTube to restore videos.
September 2 - Live Action launches first press release and public media response to force YouTube to back down.
September 4 - Google CEO Eric Schmidt is questioned why the Live Action Films videos were removed from YouTube (watch). He says he will, "look into it". Google has not responsed to our inquiry yet.
September 5 - YouTube yanks a 5th Live Action Films video, this time citing a "alleged privacy
violation".
September 9 - Live Action launches second press release. YouTube has still not contacted Live Action in anyway despite the fact that they have our email and phone number.
Live Action Emails YouTube Content Partnership Manager George Strompolos asking for him to look into our case. Read Email.